Article Summary: 

  • Saltwater pools generate chlorine naturally through electrolysis, providing consistent sanitation.
  • Saltwater pools have “softer” water that can be more pleasant to swim in. 
  • Traditional chlorine pools offer strong sanitation but can be more irritating to swimmers.
  • A maintenance professional is highly recommended to ensure the most sanitary and enjoyable swimming conditions, regardless of your preference. 


If you are in the market for a new pool, then naturally, you will be contemplating the age-old question: chlorine or saltwater? Beyond the basics of installation and upkeep, health and comfort are key factors to weigh.

Chlorine pools are widely used and known for their strong sanitizing power—but they can sometimes cause skin or eye irritation and leave a noticeable smell after swimming. Saltwater pools, on the other hand, are often seen as a gentler alternative, offering softer-feeling water and a milder swimming experience.

That said, saltwater systems require careful maintenance to avoid issues like equipment corrosion or water imbalance. Understanding the pros and cons of each will help you make the right choice for your lifestyle—and we’re here to guide you through it.

How Do Saltwater Pools Work?
Saltwater pools use a special generator to convert dissolved pool salt into chlorine, which keeps your water clean and sanitized—without the need for traditional chlorine tablets or liquid. As the water circulates, the system creates a steady, low dose of chlorine, which then turns back into salt after doing its job. It’s a simple, continuous process.

One of the biggest benefits? The water tends to feel softer and is typically gentler on the skin and eyes. But keep in mind—these systems aren’t as effective in colder weather. In places like the Hamptons, when water temperatures drop below 60°F, chlorine production slows, and many systems shut off entirely around 50°F. If you’re hoping to use your pool year-round, a heater is a smart addition.

Things to Keep in Mind with Saltwater Pools

Saltwater pools are often considered gentler on the body, but they still require consistent care to stay safe and comfortable. If salt levels dip too low, chlorine production can drop, which may allow bacteria or algae to develop over time. These changes aren’t always visible right away, so regular testing is key.

Additionally, saltwater pools tend to have naturally higher pH levels, which—if left unbalanced—can lead to cloudy water and occasional skin or eye irritation.

With proper upkeep and routine monitoring, these issues are easily preventable. A trusted pool professional can help keep everything balanced, giving you peace of mind and a more enjoyable swim.

How Do Chlorine Pools Work? 

Chlorine pools—also known as conventional pools—use chlorine-based products to keep the water clean by killing bacteria, algae, and other contaminants. It’s a tried-and-true system that many homeowners prefer for its simplicity and effectiveness.

Chlorine can be added in liquid, tablet, or granular form and works best when water temperatures are between 75–85°F. In hotter weather, it tends to break down more quickly, and in colder conditions, it becomes less effective. That’s why regular testing and adjustments are important—especially if you want to keep things comfortable and swim-ready throughout the season.

Keeping Chlorine Levels in Check

Chlorine pools are relatively easy to maintain, but they still require consistency. Too little chlorine, and the water may become cloudy or allow bacteria and algae to grow. Too much, and swimmers may experience irritation to the eyes, skin, or scalp.

It’s also worth noting that a strong chlorine smell isn’t always a sign of cleanliness. That odor usually comes from chloramines—compounds that form when chlorine interacts with sweat, sunscreen, and other contaminants. These can cause mild discomfort and reduce chlorine’s effectiveness.

The good news? With balanced levels and a thoughtful maintenance routine, chlorine pools provide a safe, reliable swimming experience all season long.

Which Option Is Right for You?

Saltwater pools tend to have a higher upfront cost (typically $1,500–$3,000 more), which is why many homeowners opt for traditional chlorine systems. But for those with sensitive skin, allergies, or respiratory concerns, the gentler feel of saltwater may be worth the investment.

Chlorine pools, while often more cost-effective to install, still require consistent maintenance to avoid over- or under-treatment—both of which can impact swimmer comfort and water quality. In the long run, the difference in maintenance costs often balances out.

Whichever option you choose, working with a pool care professional ensures your water stays clean, balanced, and safe—so you can enjoy your pool without the guesswork.

The Bottom Line

Your pool should feel as good as it looks. At Tortorella, we believe great design is only the beginning. Our expert maintenance services ensure your system runs smoothly and your water stays pristine—day in and day out.

Whether you swim year-round or just in the summer months, we’re here to help you get the most out of your investment. Explore our portfolio to see the caliber of our work, or contact us to get started with a tailored care plan that fits your pool and your lifestyle.